Thursday, 17 January 2019

Marton New Plymouth Line [2A]: Westmere-Waitotara 1

I have now finished mapping most of the Whanganui area except for East Town and have decided to do a full Volume 4 with aerial photography for the entire route to New Plymouth, branches and the SOL. There will not be any more Retrolens historical stuff done for MNPL as there are no images available for the area, so what is traced onto the map will be what can be seen from the ground in the base imagery only.

At the moment I am getting all the aerial photography needed downloaded from the LINZ site and imported into Qgis which takes a while to sort through. Overlaps at the edges of different batches of aerial imagery are another complication to be resolved.

I have completed mosaics for East Town and the Castlecliff Branch using the aerial photography I was able to obtain. The initial attempt at a mosaic for the Castlecliff route used 0.1 m aerial coverage for Whanganui City which proved to be very demanding to work with as it required up to 64 individual map tiles and massive enlargement of the historical images which resulted in a 12 GB file taxing the computer's memory significantly. Redoing it in 0.3 m aerial coverage only needed up to 16 tiles and produced a 2 GB file. The resolution of the base imagery is unimportant for mosaic tiles because the historical stuff is what is actually visible as we are only using the base to align the historical stuff to for georeferencing and when we need to display the modern imagery the 0.1 metre stuff can be separately loaded in the GIS.

Although no Retrolens coverage is presently available, occasionally there is enough on the current aerials plus a really good Whites Aviation picture for it to be worth while to create a station layout by estimating the size and position of various features in relation to known existing ones and so I drew this diagram of what Kai Iwi used to look like. The WA coverage was from 1949 and 1955 when the station was open, and also confirms the bridge realignment just upmile of the station.


 Here we can see that Kai Iwi was a busy little station in its day, it had the usual things you'd see in a rural station, including five houses for staff. The current station building, which I assume Kiwirail has sold off, is probably concrete, a replacement for the wooden one shown in the earlier pictures which was much larger, and it still sits there on the platform. Pretty much everything else has disappeared. No idea on when the bridge was replaced. The Kai Iwi crossing loop, which appears to be, like Ruatangata, a recent addition (late 2000s) with the extension of CTC on the route, can be seen going out of the east side of the image. The siding which comes off at the west end is not part of the original station layout, so we can assume nothing was left of the original station when the present loop was installed. Prior to the extension of the CTC, only Marton-Whanganui was worked by it, with electric train tablet on other parts of the MNPL converted to track warrant, as well as automatic signalling on the SOL to track warrant. I am unsure as to how far the CTC runs on the MNPL now.

Just to add to all the existing mileage controversies, the Quail Atlas, which created one with their metric distances that vary from the ones in the Working Time Table, has in the first edition used different mileages from the ones I have used on these MNPL maps. Kai Iwi as an example is shown as being at "148.09" miles. Likewise their distance for Marton on the NIMT is shown as being "311.02" miles from Auckland, or "112.00" miles from Wellington. The respective distances from the documentation I am using (NZR W&W track mileage diagrams) puts Marton at 116 miles 28 chains from Wellington and 309 miles 37 chains from Auckland. These distances are the same as the ones in the NZRLS 1947 WTT reprint that is a secondary source for me. Hence once again where have the Quail people got their distances from. Going all the way back to Wellington the early distances are correct and the possible sources of error not at all obvious, but they just gradually creep in.

As far as I am concerned the maps will keep using the mileage sources they currently have, and the key and each PDF volume will have explanatory notes about the mileages (another issue for the maps is I have converted miles and chains into decimal miles, so that the decimal point means the same thing for both imperial and metric distances which are intermingled all throughout the maps). Where some of the Quail stuff comes from is not clear, unless they have a more recent imperial WTT as a source. The problem with changing sources is that the stations that have since closed will not appear in the newer source. This is why I am currently attempting to source a early metric era WTT to have as much metric data from a WTT as possible, and not showing any metric distances other than those which can be obtained from a WTT.

Sunday, 13 January 2019

Marton New Plymouth Line [1A]: Whanganui-Castlecliff 1

I am currently looking to bring the maps from Marton to Westmere, the first 50 km of the MNPL, to a conclusion in the next week or so. Probably these will be released as a full set of maps, along with the existing diagrams of the rest of Volume 4. But there may not be a PDF produced at this stage. I am not ruling out an interim PDF, but ideally I still need to find a 1974 era working timetable to be able to include the metric distances for as many stations as possible without reliance on the suspect Quail Atlas distances. Putting in km pegs and bridge numbers without otherwise updating is a quick solution on the existing diagrams and I may allow extra time to achieve just that. I do have all the resources needed to put in WNPL distances and those will be shown along with anything else I can get from official sources.

Here are some recent screen captures:
 Castlecliff station (the sidings have not been adjusted to fit the aerial photo, as is commonly necessary when aerial photos replace diagrams)
 A zoom out to take in the general area of Castlecliff with the various wharf sheds and sidings.
 The area of what used to be Wanganui and in the days of the separate Castlecliff railway, the Town station at the beginning of their line. The Castlecliff line was re-routed several times.
 A look at how things have changed at Aramoho in the last few years. The points used to be right at the end of the bridge, with the frog on the far side, and the road crossing being over the four closer rails. This arrangement which was put in place about thirty years ago has been abandoned around 2014 in favour of having the entire set of points located on the west side of the road. This meaning the curves are sharper but making it easier to maintain the points.
General overview of Aramoho and this one shows the fertiliser factory to the north which had its sidings, some of the track still in place at the present.
Another view of Aramoho Junction that attempts to depict the back leg of the triangle. For the vast majority of its existence this leg did not actually follow the route that I have shown, but until I can get aerial photos of Aramoho in any time frame it is not going to be possible to be totally accurate. However the above will be altered in some way.

Right now I am looking at the Castlecliff line as I do have some aerial photos from 1967 covering most of it although the detail is not too sharp but I do hope with the help from Whites Aviation as well to be able to get that sorted out next week.


National Railway Museum is too small to go it alone

The National Rail Museum is a rail heritage group based at Ferrymead Heritage Park in Christchurch. A date of establishment isn't something I could put my finger on right now, but I am guessing 2003 would be an approximation but it could well be earlier than that. I do recall a number of events taking place in 2003 which appeared to be focused around some sort of official launch.

In fifteen years progress has been slow. Whilst there have been a number of railway vehicles acquired during this time frame, the construction of their key building has been quite gradual. The building is to be a roundhouse, and so far what has been completed is the turntable and the track leading into it.

When I started in rail heritage in the 1980s (which I eventually exited from around the same 2003) there was a lot more going for the various groups in terms of resources, because we lived in a different kind of society where people had more free time and money to give to these groups. The situation is now very different and the various groups find they have to work together a lot more, and some have folded up. Against that reality it's very hard for a new group to be formed and established. The other key factor which has changed a lot is the structure of the national railway network which has been through a process of corporatisation, privatisation and nationalisation. The extent to which the national network has been able to support rail heritage has changed vastly in that time, and is currently a fraction of what it used to be.

The key problems I see for the NRM are as follows:
  • It's on the Ferrymead site yet it is a separate organisation
  • It is a self established group rather than being a national initiative
  • It competes for funds and resources with every other rail heritage group in NZ rather than cooperating with them.
Being on the Ferrymead site will bring competition with every other Ferrymead society and the way it is set up is to be completely independent from even the Ferrymead Railway to which its track connects. As well, they now have a bus in their collection, which brings them into competition with two other groups at Ferrymead which preserve buses.

It can't be denied that when you are in competition with other established groups on the same site that you are all competing for members time, members funds and external funding sources.  The nature of the NRM is that they are completely separate from the Ferrymead Railway, with their own collection that they have acquired independently of that group. Whereas, it may have made more sense for them to be a subcommittee of the Ferrymead Railway and simply borrowing some of their existing vast collection of rolling stock.

Also being at Ferrymead sets them up to be in competition with other rail heritage sites in NZ, most of which are openly or not so openly competing against each other and it's doubtful there will be much support from rail heritage groups in other centres, such is the nature of rail heritage that there is nowhere near as much cooperation as there should or could be. Many of these groups will view the NRM as another group like them rather than being something they should support as a national initiative. The politics of being at Ferrymead, which tends to come across as a grandiose pretentious organisation due to their existence at a nationally significant site, will count majorly against them.

I think that the best future for the NRM would be as a branch of Rail Heritage Trust and established around New Zealand with the rolling stock and exhibits at a number of sites rather than being in one single place, thus being able to attract more widespread support. In my view RHTNZ has achieved much more in creating a national railway heritage collection and initiatives around NZ than NRM has achieved to date, and they have also been able to source additional funding support which NRM would not be able to access.

If on the other hand NRM chooses to stay at Ferrymead then they should merge with the Ferrymead Railway and focus on being a branch of that institution rather than duplicating everything which they are doing at the moment and therefore competing with them for resources.

This post is not part of any regular diversion from the core purposes of NZ Rail Maps and I do not expect to be commenting on this type of non-core topic more than once a year at this stage.